He didn’t know her name. Nor did he know who lived in the nearby squat, ranch-style house with beige siding, set back from the rural Wisconsin road by a cluster of trees shedding golden leaves.
On the third visit, he would not leave alone
Behind the wheel of his old Ford Taurus, facing the taillights on the idling bus, Patterson’s elaborate plot began to take shape.
Investigators said he provided chilling details of his crime in a lengthy confession, including his insistence he never would have been caught had he just “planned everything perfectly.”
Still, by his own admission, Patterson “put quite a bit of thought” into every detail.
For one, he took his father’s 12-gauge Mossberg shotgun, a fairly common weapon he believed would be hard to track. He grabbed half a dozen shotgun shells, then put on gloves and wiped them for prints. At Walmart, he picked up a black balaclava.
He shaved his face and head, so he’d leave no forensic evidence. At one point, he stole the plates from a parked car, then switched them with his own. He disconnected his car’s dome light to help conceal his appearance. He cut a cord that could unlock the trunk from the inside.
Twice, Patterson drove to Jayme’s home in Barron, a northwestern Wisconsin city of 3,300 residents about 90 miles east of Minneapolis. Cars in the driveway scared him away the first time. A night or two later, he aborted his plan after spotting lights and people in the house.
On October 15, though, he would not leave alone.
She knew her father was dead
He wore brown, steel-toed boots, a black jacket and jeans. The mask concealed his round, bespectacled face. Gloves covered his hands. The Taurus coasted into the Closs family driveway early that Monday morning with its headlights off.
Jayme was asleep in her bedroom when her dog, Molly, started barking. She got up, saw the car and rushed to wake her parents. Her father James, 56, headed for the front door.
Patterson shifted into park, stepped out quietly and walked to the redbrick entrance stairs. Fallen leaves surrounded decorative pumpkins and a pair of blue lawn chairs.
Jayme and her mother Denise, 46, took cover in the bathroom. They locked and barricaded the door with a cabinet drawer. Mother and daughter stepped into the tub and swung shut the shower curtain.
Behind white blinds at a window to the left of the front door, James Closs stood with a flashlight.
Get on the ground, Patterson hollered.
James Closs did not move. His flashlight illuminated the window.
Patterson climbed the brick stairs and opened the storm door. He pounded on the wooden door. Jayme’s father looked at him through a small, wrought iron-encased window pane in the middle of the door.
Show me your badge, James Closs demanded, mistaking Patterson for a cop.
He stared through the glass, down the chrome-plated shotgun barrel. Patterson pulled the trigger.
The blast shook Jayme, who cowered in the tub. She knew her father was dead. Her mother dialed 911 on her cell phone.
He turned his head and squeezed the trigger
It was about 12:53 a.m. when the call came into the Barron County Dispatch Center, three miles from the Closs family home. No one spoke. Dispatchers heard screaming. One dispatcher returned the call and got Denise Closs’ voicemail.
Outside, Patterson tried to break open the door. He ejected a spent shell and unloaded a blast toward the doorknob. He pushed the door open and stepped over James Closs’ body.
A flashlight in hand, Patterson stalked the rooms. One door wouldn’t budge. He checked the rest of the house: vacant. He returned to the bolted door. He couldn’t kick it open. He rammed it with his shoulder, over and over. The drawer. It took 10 to 15 blows from the upper half of his 6-foot, 215-pound frame before it split in two.
He ripped down the shower curtain. Denise Closs clung to her daughter in what the intruder would describe as a “bear hug.”
He handed Denise Closs duct tape and ordered her to cover her daughter’s mouth. When she struggled, Patterson rested his weapon on the sink and did it himself. He also bound Jayme’s wrists and ankles and helped her out of the tub.
He pointed the shotgun at her mother’s head and squeezed the trigger as he turned his head away.
Patterson then grabbed the 5-foot, 100-pound teenager and nearly slipped on the bloodied floor on the way out. He dragged her across the yard and forced her into the trunk of the Taurus. In all, he spent four minutes at the house.
Three Barron County Sheriff’s deputies were already on their way.
Patterson removed his mask. The shotgun laid next to him. He pressed the gas pedal. But only 20 seconds into his getaway, he was slowing for blinking lights and blaring sirens.
Patterson was ready for a gunfight, later telling investigators he “most likely would have shot at the police” if they’d stopped him.
In the trunk, Jayme heard the sirens. Then, they faded away.
At the Closs family home, deputies discovered the bodies around 1 a.m.; Jayme was gone. The deep drone of an Amber Alert soon buzzed cell phones across the state.
The door sign read: ‘Patterson’s Retreat’
For three months, police and volunteers across northern Wisconsin searched for her. Detectives chased thousands of tips. The FBI offered a $25,000 reward for information. Her parents’ employer added another $25,000.
Jayme’s photo circulated on posters. Strangers attended her parents’ funeral. Neighbors gathered at events in her honor. Relatives appealed to the public for information about where she could possibly be.
The whole time, Patterson was holding Jayme in a cluttered, single-family home near the tiny and heavily forested town of Gordon, population 650, just 70 miles north of where she lived. A sign atop the front door greets visitors to the beige and brown two-bedroom home, set on 2.6 secluded acres: “Patterson’s Retreat,” it reads.
In the basement fireplace, he’d burned her clothes, the duct tape and his gloves. He’d had Jayme change into his sister’s pajamas. He was surprised to find no blood spatter on his boots or clothing.
Patterson forced Jayme to stay under his twin-size bed, shutting her in with bags, laundry bins and barbells when visitors arrived or he left the house. When his father came on Saturdays, he turned up the bedroom radio to muffle her movements.
He said he kept her in line by yelling and hitting the walls, especially the two times he noticed she had tried to get out from under the bed. He repeatedly warned that “bad things would happen to her if she tried” to come out.
During one outburst, Jayme said Patterson struck her “really hard” on her back. She sometimes stayed under the bed for as long as 12 hours, with no food, water or access to the bathroom.
She stepped into a cold, unfamiliar world
For a time, he kept the loaded shotgun outside the bedroom in the case the police came.
But two weeks after the kidnapping, he put the weapon away. Patterson later told detectives he believed “he had gotten away” with his crimes.
“I’m an honest and hardworking guy,” he wrote under the “Skills” heading on his resume. “Not much work experience but I show up to work and am a quick learner.”
That morning, Patterson had told Jayme he was going out for a few hours. And Jayme made a decision: She’d be caged no longer. She shoved the bins and weights away from the bed. Then, she crawled out from the 2½ feet that separated the mattress from the cold floor.
Freedom at her grasp, she unlocked the front door and stepped out into an unfamiliar, snowy landscape wearing only pajamas and her captor’s sneakers on the wrong feet.
“Did she run away?” Nutter asked herself of the teenager. “Did somebody dump her off here?”
The girl came closer.
“I’m lost and I don’t’ know where I am and I need help,” the teen said.
Nutter recognized her face. Maybe from flyers or the countless television news stories.
“I’m Jayme,” said the girl, frightened but calm.
Nutter knew that name.
‘This is Jayme Closs! Call 911 right now’
She held Jayme tightly as they walked to the nearest home.
Kristin Kasinskas heard pounding on her door. Her neighbor stood outside with a skinny girl with unkempt hair and oversized sneakers.
“This is Jayme Closs!” Nutter told her. “Call 911 right now.”
Inside, fear crept over Nutter. What if the kidnapper came looking for Jayme?
“Get a weapon,” she told Kasinskas.
“Douglas County 911,” a dispatcher answered.
“Hi. I have a young lady at my house right now, and she has said her name is Jayme Closs,” Kasinskas said.
“Have you seen her photo, ma’am?”
“Yes. It is her. I 100% think it is her.”
Nutter soon took the phone. She said Jayme didn’t know where she was but had told them that a young man named Jake Patterson had killed her parents and kidnapped her. Nutter said he lived a few doors from her cabin.
“We’re kind of scared because he might come,” Nutter said.
But the dispatcher was still stuck at the start, asking, “And she said, ‘I am Jayme Closs?'”
“Yes,” Kasinskas said. “She said, ‘He killed my parents. I want to go home. Help me.'”
Catching on to the panic, the dispatcher assured the women authorities were on their way. “Ma’am, my deputy, she just wants you to lock the doors … and don’t let the dogs out or anything. Just everybody stay inside until I can get deputies there.”
“Are they close?” Nutter asked. “We’re nervous.”
Deputies pulled up to the house just before sunset, at 4:43 p.m. But even then, Nutter couldn’t trust they were safe.
“We need to let them in, right?” she asked over the 911 line.
Near her secret prison, a startling admission
When Patterson got home, Jayme was gone. He searched the house, then went outside and noticed her footprints. He got back into the Taurus to hunt her down.
Just then, a deputy ferrying Jayme away from the Kasinskas’ home spotted a red vehicle — a Kia or a Ford — approaching from the other direction. Jayme couldn’t say whether it was her abductor. The deputy alerted her colleagues.
Patterson by now had restored the original plates to his car. A license plate check by police showed the vehicle was registered to someone with the surname Patterson. An officer saw a male driver alone in the car and followed it past the house they’d soon come to learn had been Jayme’s secret prison.
Two sergeants stopped the Taurus. One ordered the driver to put his hands up, then opened the door.
Jake Patterson identified himself. He said he knew what this was about.
“I did it.”